The Quebec Federation of Real Estate Boards (QFREB) is taking the federal government to task, requesting legislation be established surrounding mortgage penalties imposed on households that prepay the full balance of their mortgage.
In Canada, when a borrower prepays the full balance of his mortgage, the lender imposes a penalty that is equal to the highest of three months of interest; or an amount based on the differential between rate A, the rate in effect at the signing of the mortgage, and rate B, the rate in effect at the prepayment date.
The second scenario allows the lender to cover the financial loss incurred by their mortgage investment in the event that interest rates decrease.
“The problem is that in the second case, some financial institutions try to maximize the difference between the two rates by using, for example, the posted rate as rate A and the negotiated rate, or a rate even lower than the negotiated rate, as rate B. As a result, the penalty paid can significantly exceed the lender’s actual loss,” says Pierre Langlois, manager of government affairs at the QFREB. “Another problem is that mortgage penalties are asymmetrical. Borrowers must pay a penalty regardless of whether interest rates increase or decrease.”
The QFREB is asking the government to enact legislation that will eliminate and prevent abuse from Canadian mortgage lenders, as it pledged to do when its budget was tabled in March 2010. The QFREB proposes four possible solutions:
– eliminate mortgage penalties in Canada;
– set limits (e.g., a minimum of three months of interest and a maximum of six months of interest);
– use the negotiated rate (rate A) and the rate that the financial institution is willing to offer for the remaining period (rate B);
– use a curve of negotiated rates established periodically by an independent organization (such as the Bank of Canada) that reflects the prevailing market conditions.
“When households learn the amount of the penalty to be paid, many of them decide to postpone the sale of their property, thereby slowing down the real estate market,” says Langlois. “Moreover, this problem adversely affects market liquidity and promotes household debt.”