Is everything old new again? My students may be tired of hearing me say so, but in lead generation I believe it is, and the reason is artificial intelligence. AI now writes our listing descriptions, drafts our emails and answers our clients’ questions before we have finished reading them. It is fast, agreeable and available at 3 a.m. But that’s not how clients choose an agent, and it is worth remembering why.
Face to face
Lead generation happens in person. Open houses are back in my area, and I am told the turnouts are good. In my own practice, they have always paid off, both in finding buyers for my sellers and in meeting buyers I would never otherwise have reached. I don’t do door knocking, but I watch agents who do it well, and although it is hard, it works. Most of all, the work is talking to people. All of them. Some of my earliest clients were my dental hygienist and the man who owned the dry cleaner I used every week.
The hygienist and the dry cleaner
I did not go to either of them looking for business. I was there for a cleaning or to drop off a bag of shirts. Over months of appointments and Saturday mornings, we talked about the weather, the neighbourhood, their families and mine. Eventually they learned what I did for a living, and when real estate came up at home, I was the person they thought of.
My hygienist eventually asked me to help her family sell their home and buy the next one. The dry cleaner came to me when he needed an agent, and then twice more over the years. When his son, a young man I had only ever known as a name in our conversations, was ready to buy, his father sent him to me.
These are some of the most satisfying transactions of my career. They happened organically. I didn’t purchase either of those leads. I built rapport, kept showing up and paid attention. Every experienced agent I know has a version of this story, and every one of us knows this is not “luck.”
The promise that never arrived
The promise of online leads has never materialized. Agents have spent enormous sums and invested real hope in portals, pay-per-click campaigns and purchased lead lists. In 16 years, I have not met one who could honestly tell me it was worth the money. The leads are cold, the conversion rates are dismal, and the people on the other end have usually clicked on a dozen listings and a dozen agents in the same afternoon.
We get our clients the way we always have: through referrals, through rapport and through long conversations where we learn what someone needs, wants and can afford.
What it means for agents
I remind myself and my students of this because we now must be clear about how we differentiate ourselves from AI. It does the paperwork faster than we can, and it never disagrees with the client. It cannot sit across a kitchen table from a nervous first-time buyer, remember that his father was worried about the furnace when he bought, or tell a seller the market has shifted. That is the job, and it is the part people are actually paying for.
So, I’ll say it again, and I’ll keep saying it. Hold the open house. Talk to the person behind the counter and the person cleaning your teeth. Let them get to know you. This is what has always worked. We were temporarily blinded by the internet’s power and thought we could buy quality leads. It was an illusion, fuelled by wishful thinking and by clever marketing from people selling us their “systems.”
Dixie MacDonald is a sales representative with Sotheby’s International Realty Canada in Prince Edward County and Quinte, with more than 16 years in residential resale. A trusted and effective Realtor, she welcomes referrals.
In addition to a B.A. in English Literature and two certificates in adult education, she holds the SRES, ABR, GREENre, CCRS, CCGR and PSA designations. She facilitates in the provincial real estate education program and is a professional development instructor with various boards and associations. She writes for REM and on Substack.
Dixie MacDonald Sales Representative Sotheby’s International Realty Canada 1867 Yonge Street, Suite 100, Toronto ON M4S 1Y5 t 416.960.9995 | f 416.960.3222 dixie.macdonald@