Select Page

Realtysellers sues TREB after MLS access cut

Toronto discount brokerage Realtysellers has launched a $41 million lawsuit against the Toronto Real Estate Board (TREB) after the board blocked Realtysellers’ access to the MLS system.  An application by Realtysellers for an injunction to have MLS access restored was denied after a November 7 court hearing.

   
“TREB disabled TorontoMLS access codes of Realtysellers in October as those codes were being used in a fashion contrary to the rules and user agreements which Realtysellers had entered into as a member of TREB,” TREB Executive Officer Don Richardson said in a statement to REM.
 
Richardson says access to TorontoMLS “was being used by another entity for wholesale extraction and display of information which is the property of TREB and its member brokerages.”
 
This is not the first legal action Realtysellers has undertaken.  In 2002, the real estate firm and Broker Stephen Moranis sued TREB and the Canadian Real Estate Association, alleging breaches of the Competition Act. That action was settled out of court for undisclosed terms.
 
In the Statement of Claim for its new lawsuit, filed on October 22, Realtysellers claims that, as a result of an initiative undertaken by CREA in 2006, “Realtysellers’ lenders ceased providing funding and Realtysellers was forced to suspend its operations in late 2006.”  That CREA initiative, as described in the Statement of Claim, required “that real estate brokers meet minimum service standards without which brokers were unable to access the MLS”. 
 
Realtysellers says that it recently entered into a joint initiative with BNV Real Estate Inc., a Bell Canada affiliate, to launch Real Estate Plus (www.realestateplus.ca), “a website which provides users access to property information available on the MLS…(and)…Realtysellers’ major lenders agreed to restart the provision of financing so it could once again become operational for the first time since late 2006 when it had been shut down as a result of the CREA initiative,” says the Statement of Claim.
 
It also says: “The decision to terminate the Realtysellers’ MLS access was the product of a conspiracy between TREB and one or more of the Directors who acted with the predominant purpose of injuring Realtysellers and/or the knowledge of the likelihood that Realtysellers would suffer harm as a result of being denied access to MLS…The actions of TREB and certain of its Directors were targeted at harming Realtysellers because it is a discount broker that provides consumers in the market for the purchase or sale of a home with a lower cost alternative to traditional brokers. This threatens traditional brokers such as the majority of TREB members and the Directors.”
 
Realtysellers is asking the court for restored access to the MLS system, as well as $10 million in general and special damages for breach of contract; $10 million in damages for conspiracy to injure; $10 million for breach of the Competition Act; $10 million for “intentional interference with economic interests” and $1 million in punitive damages.
 
“TREB absolutely denies any of the allegations in the Realtysellers’ Statement of Claim,” TREB EO Richardson says in his statement to REM, adding that TREB “will continue to protect the rights of TREB, its members and the public, and (we) look forward to an expedited legal action to settle this matter.”
 
The broker of record for BNV Real Estate is 30-year real estate veteran Fraser Beach. A blog entry by Beach says that as members of CREA and TREB, BNV Real Estate and Realtysellers “must comply with all requirements of regulators, real estate boards and real estate associations.
 
“However, we don’t always agree with some of the rules and procedures required by the boards and associations, particularly those that do not promote the best interests of consumers. But we recognize the need to work within the industry to bring about meaningful change.”  Another BNV website blog explains that “the website is not the Toronto MLS system, and does not display all of the listing information associated with a property in the Toronto Real Estate Board’s database. But unlike mls.ca, it does display recently sold properties.”
 

Share this article: