The lobbying efforts of Toronto Real Estate Board members paid off, at least temporarily, when the City of Toronto deferred a decision on a proposed second land transfer tax. The proposed levy, of up to two per cent, would make it Canada’s highest land transfer tax and could cost the average Toronto homebuyer more than $15,000 over the life of a mortgage.
However, the decision to defer the vote until after the provincial election, in the hopes that the city’s financial woes will become a provincial election issue, has been controversial. After the deferral vote, Toronto Mayor David Miller instructed staff to cut $100,000 million from the city’s operating budget, which has resulted in a number of service cuts.
After City Council voted to defer the issue until its October 22 meeting, Miller told the Globe and Mail, “I underestimated the impact that TREB’s campaign was having on individual members of council who were undecided.”
TREB told the city that it must ensure that its own house is in order and that all creative solutions have been examined before considering such a drastic measure. TREB voiced concerns that by making it more expensive to live in Toronto, the tax would contradict the provincial government’s plans to prevent urban sprawl. It would also hurt Toronto’s economy, which would impact the entire province.
In a further effort to get the message out to consumers, TREB launched a special website, www.NoHomeBuyingTax.com. In less than a month, the site received more than 11,200 visits. TREB also declared its opposition to the proposed tax increase in full-page advertisements in the Toronto Star, which were complemented by ads in community newspapers.
TREB is now urging its members and their clients to email key provincial politicians in addition to city councillors, in an effort to make the proposed second land transfer tax a provincial election issue. TREB President Donald Bentley says responsibility for Toronto’s fiscal woes must be shared by all.
“Provincial action is a key part of the solution to Toronto’s financial challenges. The provincial government must adequately support Toronto. Expecting the city to, instead, penalize home buyers with a 100 per cent increase to land transfer taxes is simply not fair.”
If the city levies this new tax, other municipalities could seek authority from the provincial government to exercise the same power, says TREB.