BY KATHY BEVAN
Realtysellers (Ontario) Inc. has launched an amended lawsuit against the Toronto Real Estate Board (TREB), to include the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and the respective CEOs and boards of directors for TREB and CREA, as well as TREB’s newspaper, Real Estate News.
In an Amended Statement of Claim filed with the Ontario Superior Court in August, Realtysellers alleges that TREB and CREA breached the Competition Act, citing “offences of conspiracy” (Section 45) and “price maintenance” (Section 61). The claim states that the defendants “have conspired and agreed among themselves to cause injury to Realtysellers or to use unlawful means to prevent Realtysellers from successfully carrying out its business”.
Specifically, Realtysellers charges that activities by the defendants have included efforts to:
– “Change the rules governing access to, and the conditions for use of, the TREB‑MLS system so as to discriminate against Realtysellers and its programs;”
– “Maintain fees and commission rates traditionally enjoyed by real estate agents and brokers at the expense of the public and to the prejudice of Realtysellers and its programs;”
– “Interfere with Realtysellers’ efforts to develop and advertise its innovative and unique products and services;”
– “Harass and inhibit Realtysellers' ability to compete in the resale residential real estate brokerage marketplace in the GTA.”
Realtysellers is alleges that CREA and its directors acted to protect a traditional fee structure within the industry, to the detriment of the 1.25 per cent listing fee service offered by Realtysellers. The firm is also alleging that TREB and its directors denied Realtysellers fair access to TREB‑MLS and that TREB’s Real Estate News breached an advertising agreement with the firm.
Some of these allegations were originally contained in a legal action initiated by Realtysellers in January 2002 against TREB and its newspaper. At that time, Realtysellers was demanding $200 million in damages. The Amended Statement of Claim has been expanded to include TREB’s CEO, Don Richardson, as well as members of TREB’s board of directors for 2002 and 2003, along with CREA’s CEO, Pierre Beauchamp, and CREA’s 2002 board of directors.
The damages being sought have been amended as well. Realtysellers is now seeking $25 million in damages, $1 million in punitive damages, as well as a further award of triple damages for violation of Section 1 of the Monopolies Act, for conduct “tending to enforce monopolistic market power concerning access to MLS and advertising services”.
As REM went to press, no Statement of Defence was available and no public comment had been made by the federal Competition Bureau, which has investigated allegations of anti‑competitive behaviour in the real estate industry in the past. However, both TREB and CREA issued official statements to their membership.
TREB president Cynthia Lai says the board’s public position is straightforward: “As this matter is before the courts, it would be improper to comment at this time. However, the Toronto Real Estate Board subscribes to a pledge of competition and believes there is no merit to this claim.”
CREA president Richard Wood’s comments were contained in a memo distributed to the national association’s members just before Realtysellers’ Amended Statement of Claim was made public. “Realtysellers’ main allegation against CREA and the 2002 directors is in essence that they manipulated MLS listing requirements to prevent Realtysellers from carrying out its plan to develop its business,” said Wood. “CREA does not of course accept Realtysellers’ allegations and expects to defend the action vigorously.”
Realtysellers was co‑founded in December 2000 by former TREB president and CREA director, Stephen Moranis, and Toronto lawyer Lawrence Dale. The firm employs 30 salaried salespeople and offers consumers the choice of a full-service 1.25 per cent listing fee, a $695 flat fee MLS listing service, or a “½ back” commission rebate program.
Moranis says that Realtysellers is not a discount brokerage. “We’re a full-service broker — we just happen to charge less.”
“We’re just trying to offer consumers a choice for buying and selling property,” says Moranis. “Consumers of residential brokerage services should be entitled to competitive prices and product and service choices.”
A court date has yet to be determined.