Select Page

Controversial ad campaign doesn’t sway Toronto vote

BY KATHY BEVAN

 

A controversial ad campaign combined with the first opportunity for all Toronto Realtors to cast a vote, brought out more than 2,000 voters to the Toronto Real Estate Board’s (TREB) general election in June. The previous board served an extended 18‑month term in office to help make the transition into a new fiscal year.

The ad campaign, sponsored by Re/Max Ontario‑Atlantic Canada, supported a slate of 13 candidates — six Re/Max and seven non‑Re/Max people. But when all the votes were tallied, only six of the 13 candidates named in the Re/Max ad were elected as directors – and three of those were by acclamation, including the only successful Re/Max candidate.

The ad thanked outgoing TREB president David Pearce and his current board of directors and the board’s executive members for getting TREB “back on track” through fiscal reforms, operating cost reductions, increased services and decreased fees.

“We believe that the people selling real estate should be active in making the decisions that affect their future. Take the time to vote,” said the full‑page ad, which ran in REM, while a set of similar ads ran in TREB’s Real Estate News. The ad then went on to name the candidates that Re/Max says shared the same vision regarding the continued direction of the board, including sitting director Paul Etherington, as candidate for president‑elect. Etherington works for Re/Max Rouge River Realty, the firm headed up by outgoing president Pearce.

The interesting twist to this public show of support: Cynthia Lai, who defeated Etherington by a vote of 1,229 to 798 and is now the new board’s president‑elect, also works for Re/Max, as broker/manager of Re/Max Goldenway Realty Inc. Lai was in agreement with reminding all Realtors about the importance of voting, but clearly did not appreciate Re/Max naming only some of the candidates vying for positions on the board.

“I was very, very disturbed to see that ad in REM. As a Re/Max member myself, I was very distressed to see my marketing fees being spent to campaign against myself,” Lai said on the morning of the election. “At Re/Max, each office is independently owned and operated. How can they arbitrarily represent each office by naming a slate, when they didn’t poll all of their members to see who we wanted to recommend?”

Independent Realtor Betty Hackett, broker/owner of Discovery Realty Ltd., who has herself run for the board in two previous elections, was also annoyed by the slate campaign.

“I don’t want anyone telling me who to vote for — especially not a big company like Re/Max,” Hackett says. “Trying to get more people out to vote, that is a good thing. But trying to get people to vote a certain way, that’s not right.”

Michael Polzler, executive vice‑president and regional director of Re/Max Ontario‑Atlantic Canada, countered criticism of his company’s ad by stressing that a number of candidates not on the Re/Max slate, including president‑elect Lai, ran very well‑organized campaigns and got out strong voter support.

“Now that every board member has the vote, we are going to see more of this real politicking going on — shaking hands and kissing babies — and that’s a positive thing,” says Polzler, who would like to see the board adopt online voting in future elections. “I think voter apathy is a shame. When you have 17,000 members and you only get 2,000 out to vote, that’s not a lot.”

Despite being disappointed with voter turnout, Re/Max is running a new ad in Ontario editions of REM, thanking the Realtors who did come out to vote, and congratulating all the winners who now make up the 2002‑2003 board. And despite the controversy the ad raised, Polzler remains unapologetic about promoting specific board candidates.

“Did we step into it too deeply? There is nothing wrong with taking a leadership position to show what we think,” says Polzler. “Our associates look to our regional office for leadership, and leadership sometimes means taking a position not everyone agrees with.”

Lai did not agree with Re/Max’s position.

“Leadership means letting the members decide who they want on the board, not telling them who they should choose,” says Lai. She adds, however, that she is looking forward to working with everyone elected to serve on the new board. “A leader should be a person who can recognize the strengths and the weaknesses of others, and work with them all. I’ve always been a bridge‑builder between people.”

Share this article: