BY KATHY BEVAN
The B.C. Real Estate Association and the Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver have come one step closer to addressing the issues that are driving them apart, and what may yet keep them together.
In September, BCREA held a meeting with the presidents and executive officers of all its member boards, to discuss Vancouver’s threaten to withdraw from BCREA next spring if substantial changes are not put into place.
Two new provincial task forces emerged from that meeting. The Industry Review Task Force, on which Vancouver is represented, is now exploring how organized real estate can be restructured in B.C. and plans to make its first report by mid-December. The Financial Review Task Force, which does not include Vancouver representatives, is looking at funding alternatives if the Vancouver board and its members’ corresponding $600,000 in annual dues leave the BCREA. Recommendations from both task forces are to be brought before BCREA’S AGM in mid-March.
While the announcement of more task forces was a disappointment to anyone expecting quick action by BCREA, association executives stressed that they wanted to ensure that some comprehensive solutions are found.
“At the end of the day, the system will be changed, but how it’s going to be changed will be the decision of all 12 boards in B.C., not just one,” says Robin Hill, executive officer of BCREA.
Whether or not there will still be 12 boards left in B.C. to make that decision may depend on the membership vote that Vancouver has scheduled for its own AGM on March 1. For the present, however, Vancouver’s executive officer, Bob Wallace, says that REBGV would rather change the system from within.
“We’re very anxious not to break up the industry. There are many reasonable solutions to this,” says Wallace.
Vancouver wants BCREA to revamp its governance structure, and its strategic planning function, among other things. REBGV has also argued that the association could significantly cut overhead expenses by leasing available office space in the Vancouver board’s building.
Several of the concerns raised by Vancouver are also being circulated to all the B.C. boards in a letter entitled a Joint Letter to the Leadership of the B.C. Real Estate Industry. The letter is endorsed by several prominent members of organized real estate in B.C.
“We see no reason to continue many of the duplications of services we see throughout the province. MLS, consumer complaints, arbitration, printing and member services could be handled from any location,” says the letter. It also calls for a timely end to the dispute between the association and the Vancouver board, and “not another task force”.
It was another task force last year — called the ‘spirit of co-operation’ — that raised expectations that organized real estate in B.C. had finally found a way to break down the MLS barriers between board jurisdictions. However, not all the boards have followed through on the commitments they made when they signed the task force’s Pledge of Co-operation last September.
BCREA wants to get those boards back on track, but first it must find a way to keep Vancouver’s support. Working in the association’s favour is the three-way agreement which Vancouver, BCREA and CREA are all party to, which gives Vancouver board members access to the Realtor and MLA trademarks.
“Under the Three-Way Agreement, there would be no relationship between the Vancouver board and CREA, if the board votes to leave the provincial association,” says CREA president Harry DeLeeuw, who notes that seven years ago, a similar issue confronted CREA when the Toronto board publicly questioned the value of belonging to the provincial and national associations. “Toronto allowed both OREA and CREA to make presentations to its members and TREB members decided that they were getting their money’s worth from the two associations.”
DeLeeuw adds that he is hopeful that BCREA and CREA will be able to make presentations to Vancouver members and persuade them of the value of continued membership in the associations as well. Otherwise, Vancouver’s use of the MLS and Realtor trademarks will be in jeopardy.
Wallace says that is something Vancouver members will have to decide.
“Whether or not we will have the ‘Vancouver Listing Service’ instead of MLS, I don’t know — that’s an emotional thing as well as a practical one,” says Wallace. “What we have heard is that CREA is willing to re-examine that (Three-Way) Agreement and find ways for all of us to work together under some new format.”