Select Page

CREA seeks consensus on MLS proposals

By Jim Adair

 

It’s back to the drawing board for CREA’s Board of Directors after controversial changes to the MLS rules and regulations were referred back to the board at the CREA Special Assembly meeting.

 

Delegates at the meeting in Halifax passed a motion “that the proposed amendments be referred to the Board of Directors for further study, with the mandate to also consider all other options for the promotion and protection of the trademarks, and that their recommendations be presented to the members at the 2007 Annual General Meeting.”

 

The resolution also instructs the CREA board to “conduct town hall style meetings with members and any other type of consultation as required.”

 

The preamble to the motion recognizes that “every effort has been made by the CREA board to strengthen its marks by recommending amendments to the MLS rules that govern the acceptance of listings under the registrations”, and that “it is highly desirable to achieve consensus within the boards/associations on the issue of MLS and Multiple Listing Service marks certification mark protection.”

 

The proposals, which would not allow FSBO listings on a board’s MLS system and would ban listings in which a seller retains the right to sell the property without involvement of a Realtor, were opposed by real estate boards in Toronto and Montreal over concerns that they may be anticompetitive. The federal Competition Bureau also expressed misgivings about the proposals, and warned that the bureau might launch an inquiry into the operation of the MLS system.

 

CREA President Alan Tennant says that the Board of Directors was not discouraged by the vote at the Special Assembly meeting, and that they are committed to finding a consensus for the issue.

 

In addition to holding meetings across the country, CREA is developing a public relations strategy to get the word out about the need to protect the MLS trademark, and refute some media reports that the association says had incorrect information. CREA is developing background materials about the issue and will also provide a “speakers bureau” that will send people to board and association events to explain the intent of the proposals.

 

The trademark issue has also re-opened the debate about the name of mls.ca. Michael Manley, a director at the Toronto Real Estate Board, told a gathering at the Atlantic Connection Conference that CREA can’t say on one hand that it wants to protect the MLS trademark, while on the other hand it is promoting a website called mls.ca on television commercials. “People go to mls.ca because they think it’s the MLS,” Manley said. “It degrades the MLS concept when you call the site mls.ca.”

 

But Ken MacKenzie, executive officer of the Fraser Valley Real Estate Board, told the audience that it took “15 years of steady progress” to bring the mls.ca site to the point where it received 2.98 million unique visitors in August alone. “You can’t just go back 15 years and start all over again just because of a little confusion in the marketplace,” he said.

 

Last year in a Guest Column in REM, MacKenzie wrote that the use of mls.ca for the website name was helping raise awareness of the MLS brand, rather than weakening it.

 

The first salvo in the public relations process was in a statement released by CREA following the vote.  “The proposed amendments to the MLS rules presented at the CREA Special Assembly in Halifax were developed to protect the trademark, and for no other reason,” says Tennant in the statement. “Some reports have suggested the proposed rules would mean higher fees for consumers, or the elimination of some real estate broker business models. The MLS Rules and the proposed amendments do not restrict or determine the fees or commissions that Realtors may charge. They are also flexible enough to permit a wide range of business models for real estate.”

 

However, the Competition Bureau still must be convinced that it is a trademark issue. In a letter to CREA, the Bureau said, “CREA has the right to exclude others from using its trademark, but not to leverage that right into restricting competition in the provision of real estate brokerage services.”

 

TREB President Dorothy Mason said her board’s main concern is that “anything we do is balanced with trade and competition.”

Share this article: