Select Page

Edmonton Realtors to vote on exploring direct CREA membership

Members of the Realtors Association of Edmonton (RAE) will vote Thursday on whether to begin the process of pursuing direct membership in the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

If passed, the motion would authorize RAE’s board of directors to apply for direct CREA membership effective no later than Feb. 28, 2028, with notice to AREA taking effect no later than Feb. 28, 2029.

According to CREA, this is the first time a local board has held a vote on becoming a direct member of the national association.

RAE board chair Darlene Reid emphasized that exploring direct membership is not the same as deciding to leave the Alberta Real Estate Association (AREA).

“The industry is changing and as we see more consolidation and efficiencies throughout organized real estate; as a board we are looking towards what structure may best serve our membership in the years to come,” Reid said in an email to REM.

“Our members’ input is extremely important to us, which is why we are bringing this question to them before we undertake to begin the process of applying for direct membership.”

Reid said the vote is intended to determine whether members support further exploration of the proposal, including the development of a formal business case and opportunities for consultation.

“The question before the membership will allow the board of directors to know if the membership wants us to begin the process of preparing for a formal vote. It will permit us to create the formal business case for them to consider and to begin planning for member town halls to hear their opinions on the pros and cons of that case.”

She added that the process would take time and that establishing deadlines would provide accountability to members.

“Exploring direct membership is not the same as deciding to leave AREA. No final decision is being made at our general meeting on Thursday. We need to hear from the members as a group before taking the next steps.”

Asked to specify how direct membership with CREA could benefit RAE members, Reid said: “That is all to be determined, if we are given direction from RAE membership to explore direct membership with CREA.”

 

AREA says members were “surprised” by the proposal

 

In a statement to REM, AREA said that several members have brought the proposal to its attention in recent days.

“Members have told AREA that the proposal to pursue direct membership in the Canadian Real Estate Association came as a surprise, and that they have not received the information they need to understand what is being proposed or how it would affect their business,” said AREA. “Members have also raised that a bylaw change removing their provincial membership was included in the meeting documents without explanation.”

AREA says it was not consulted on these proposals and does not support the move to direct membership.

“AREA believes members should have complete information before they make decisions, including which services members would lose if they voted to leave AREA.”

AREA says it remains open to discussing these matters with RAE members and its board.

 

CREB, RAE look at possible merger

 

Reid confirmed that RAE and the Calgary Real Estate Board (CREB) “are in the initial phase of discussing a potential merger.”

The potential for the merger is outlined in a webpage for members, which references “challenges” both RAE and CREB have been presented with by AREA, as well as the exclusion of certain services and benefits by AREA.

Asked to clarify which services and benefits RAE and CREB are being excluded from, Reid said: “AREA is currently suing RAE and CREB. As this is currently before the courts, we are unable to comment.”

In January, AREA and CEO Brad Mitchell filed a statement of claim in the Court King’s Bench of Alberta against CREB, RAE and past and present leadership from each board. The claim points to alleged disputes that came after a failed 2023 vote to amalgamate CREB with AREA.

CREB is also now considering whether direct CREA membership could benefit its members.

“CREB is in the early stages of exploring the pros and cons of direct membership with CREA,” said Alan Tennant, CREB’s president and CEO, in an email to REM.

“The process requires extensive consideration and eventually meaningful member input, all of which takes time.”

Tennant said the discussions reflect broader changes being considered across organized real estate.

“The entire real estate space is contemplating changes of various magnitude. With matters around membership, the affected membership base has to see value in what is being proposed.”

CREB, with more than 8,600 members, and RAE, with more than 5,500, represent 89 per cent of the 15,800 Realtors AREA supports.

 

What CREA’s rules require

 

Under CREA’s bylaws and rules, a local board seeking direct membership must meet several requirements before its application can be considered.

Among them is the preparation of a business case outlining which provincial products and services would cease, how they would be replaced and the estimated costs of doing so.

The board must also engage its provincial association in good-faith discussions aimed at resolving any outstanding issues, which may include mediation.

Once those steps have been completed, a formal motion to withdraw from the provincial association and apply for direct CREA membership must receive at least two-thirds support from voting board members at a duly called membership meeting.

The application would then go before CREA’s board of directors for consideration. If approved, direct membership would take effect one year after CREA’s board passes its motion.

Share this article: