Select Page

Maureen O’Neill is TREB’s new president-elect

By Don Procter

Maureen O'Neill has been elected president-elect of the Toronto Real Estate Board, after a hard-fought campaign with Michael Manley. 

The two candidates vying for the post couldn’t have been more divided on key issues. 

Riding on a platform of change,  Manley said that mls.ca needs an overhaul because it is unfair to buyer agents. Last year it registered 93 million visits and 3.2 million emails went directly to the listing agent. “All the benefits of the current system go to the listing agent; all of the leads go to the listing agent,” says Manley, owner of Prudential Properties Plus, which has about 100 agents. 

But O’Neill argues that mls.ca works for co-operating brokers as well because their clients call them when they see an interesting property on mls.ca for sale. She says that listing agents should get more calls because they are advertising the property. “Mls.ca is an advertising medium. It’s the same as when brokers advertise ‘For Sale’ signs on a property’s lawn: they get calls, as they should,” she says. 

Manley says agents with a lot of listings who have little interest in working with buyers, nonetheless find themselves landing buyers through mls.ca. They form financial and contractual relationships with buyer agents.

He says the industry has never fully embraced the idea of giving buyer agents equal representation since the province created buyer/seller regulations in 1995. The current rules of mls.ca only make matters worse for buyer agents. “It is just like it was before 1995 when the government said it wasn’t right.”

O’Neill, a broker/manager at Bosley Real Estate, counters that few listing agents actually sell their properties; double ending represents less than 10 per cent of all sales. She says Manley’s proposal is a divisive one for the industry. “It pits salesperson against salesperson. In the end consumers lose.” 

Manley says he favours moving to an Internet Data Exchange (IDX) system because through it, all TREB MLS listings could be shown on an agent’s website with that agent listed as the contact person, even though they are not the listing agent. The listing agent would not be advertised, only the listing brokerage.

Furthermore, since the system would come from TREB servers, there would be no information time lag. Right now mls.ca users look up many properties with outdated information, he says. In some cases homes have already been sold or properties coming onto the market aren’t yet listed on mls.ca. 

O’Neill says while it takes up to two days before a listing makes it to mls.ca, “That’s still pretty good. Don’t forget, it is an advertising site only; it is not an MLS system. A lot of brokers don’t put their listings on it.”

The real estate board is looking at how IDX could work. One stipulation, O’Neill says, is that it would have to be under a reciprocal arrangement. “If somebody wants to use IDX, it should be done with the listing broker’s permission.” 

Manley says there is proof that IDX works. Just look to the U.S. where a number of real estate boards use it, he says. The London and St. Thomas Association of Realtors also adopted it. He says when he proposed IDX as a solution to mls.ca at a TREB board meeting recently, everyone was in favour, including his opponent in the presidential race, Maureen O’Neill. That surprised him because “Maureen has said before that I’m trying to destroy our MLS system,” he says. Manley had pledged that if he won the election, he would move to have a task force look into the logistics of IDX.

Manley also advocates changes to how multiple offers are handled. Under the current system the listing agent has a “big advantage” over co-operating agents because he or she is the only one privy to information in all the offers, including the price. It is unfair to the other agents and their clients, he says.

His proposal calls for a fair offer system that might include an online site that is accessible to buyer agents who must obtain a deposit from their client to qualify for bidding. Specifics of each bid would be confidential, but “an offer ranking system” would be disclosed, showing each party where they stand in the bidding process. 

O’Neill prefers to leave the current multiple offer system alone. “Why change what works well?” she says. Agents that abuse it are accountable to rules laid out by the TREB and the Real Estate Council of Ontario, she says. Furthermore, each broker can set their own standards to ensure the multiple offer system is fair and equitable. At her office, for instance, when a listing agent gets an offer, Bosley’s management handles it. “It’s very impartial and very objective.”

Another contentious area for Manley concerns rules about multiple agency representation. A study in 2003 showed that of 2,100 property sales in the Toronto area, 24 per cent were multiple representation sales, of which nine per cent were “true double-enders”.

“Twenty-four per cent leads to a lot of confusion and nine per cent leads to a conflict of interest,” he says. In essence if an agent has a listing, every agent working for that broker is in a multiple-agency representation relationship, meaning they can’t give their clients advice on the property. “It’s crazy because they aren’t representing the best interest of their clients.”
 
That’s not entirely true, says his opponent, noting that agents in the same office as a listing agent can provide their clients with advice; they are, however, under obligation to a confidentiality agreement regarding price and motivation. “If the seller at the table asks us if our clients will go up in price, we can’t tell them. Before these changes (regulations) came about we had to work for the seller and tell them so the system in place now is actually better.”  

Manley says he’d prefer to see a designated agent system in which only the listing agent, not the broker, is beholden to the client. The idea would particularly impact larger realty offices with many agents, he says.
 
O’Neill says while Manley’s platform was all about changing things, change is not always a good thing. “I don’t concur with the saying, ‘If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it’, but if something is working so successfully,” why wrangle with it?”   

 

Share this article: