In an open letter to Toronto Mayor David Miller, the Toronto Real Estate Board (TREB) has raised concerns about a possible home-buying tax in Toronto. The city is looking at new ways to raise revenue to ease the burden on property taxes, including the possibility of a new land transfer tax, which would be levied on top of the existing provincial land transfer tax.
“Let’s call a spade a spade. A land transfer tax is a home-buying tax,” says TREB President Dorothy Mason in the letter. “It is a tax charged directly to home buyers when they purchase a property, which is usually intended to offset costs for providing services directly related to real estate transactions. If the city intends to charge a land transfer tax just to raise additional revenue for general municipal services, is it fair to expect home buyers to pay for services that the whole community benefits from?
“If the city adopts a land transfer tax, Toronto home buyers will be faced with a double whammy of land transfer taxes – a municipal land transfer tax and a provincial land transfer tax,” says Mason.
TREB says for the average Toronto home, the provincial land transfer tax payable is approximately $4,200.
“If the city moves ahead with a second land transfer tax of 0.5 per cent, as is being considered, average Toronto home buyers could be faced with paying almost $1,900 on top of the $4,200 that they already have to pay for the existing provincial land transfer tax, money that could be spent on other expenses when purchasing a home such as appliances,” says Mason. “That’s an additional 45 per cent in land transfer tax. Even a 0.1 per cent Toronto land transfer tax would represent almost a 10 per cent increase in land transfer taxes. Also, with total closing costs (legal fees, land transfer tax) usually around 1.5 per cent of a property’s selling price, a 0.5 per cent Toronto land transfer tax would represent a 33 per cent increase in closing costs,” says Mason.
“Mayor Miller and all of City Council should realize that forcing home buyers to pay a second land transfer tax will have implications for the city. It will make Toronto housing less affordable, and encourage home buyers to choose to live outside of the city, where they only have to pay the land transfer tax once. This could mean more commuting, more traffic, and environmental impacts, like smog, for the GTA,” Mason says.