Select Page

TREB president grilled about $2.7-million TV-MLS write-off

By Jim Adair

 

When Ontario Premier Mike Harris took to the podium to address the Toronto Real Estate Board’s annual meeting recently, he got a laugh from the packed audience when he said, “I appreciate that I don’t have to answer questions about fees, dues, the TREB website and things that appear controversial.”

 

But TREB president David Pearce didn’t get off so easy later in the meeting, as members grilled him about accountability following the decision to write off more than $2.7-million spent on the TV- MLS development project. The Real Estate Board of Greater Vancouver, TREB’s partner in the project, wrote off $700,000 when the project was abandoned in December.

 

Recalling other TREB financial scandals from recent years – a costly project involving electronic lock boxes, and allegations that the 1999 past-president had overspent expense accounts by $80,000 — members at the meeting asked how future boards of directors could be held more accountable to members.

 

Asked if any of the $2,738,632 spent on the TV project is recoverable, Pearce said: “I doubt that any of the money is recoverable. There are some negotiations as we wind up….I was going to say the contract, but unfortunately a former CEO proceeded with this program without a contract. There’s nothing in writing… Bad decisions were made. No one here made those decisions, and quite frankly, I don’t think there’s a hell of a lot we can do about it.”

 

Another member received applause for asking if a bylaw could be passed “to prevent future boards from making decisions without asking members.”

 

Pearce replied: “It wasn’t the board of directors who got us into this contract, it was a former CEO who is no longer with us….This started three years ago and the individuals involved, the CEO, CIO and the former president, they made the decision to proceed, and none of them are associated with TREB anymore.”

 

Pressed about how another situation like this one can be avoided, Pearce said new CEO Don Richardson has instituted a series of checks and balances that will ensure that no new contracts are put in place until there are at least three quotes in place. But Pearce said that policy already existed and in the past was sometimes ignored by board staff.

 

Another member said he supported the decision to dump the project but was concerned that two previous boards of directors kept assuring members that the TV project was on track. “I believe past boards or presidents owe us an apology for this matter,” he said, to much applause. Later in the meeting, another member said, “You can’t blame the outgoing CEO for all the scandals – it’s the boards of directors who must take the blame.”

 

Pearce said: “As a member of the board of directors in 1999 and 2000, I accept responsibility.”

 

The board is currently tendering for a new “off-the-shelf” MLS system.

 

“Members first” has been adopted as the new theme at TREB, as the board returns to its not-for-profit roots. But Richardson told the annual meeting that “not for profit does not mean not efficient” and that the interim budget for 2001 calls for a $1-million surplus. The meeting was told that despite the huge write-off, the board has a strong balance sheet and no long-term debt.



Another of TREB’s new mantras is that there will be no secrets from members, and to this end, the annual meeting was opened to the press for the first time. Although throngs of electronic and print media were present for Harris’ speech, most of them left when the premier did and by the time the Q&A sessions started, REM was the lone representative at the media table.

 

The meeting also featured an on-the-spot survey of the opinions of those members at the meeting, through the use of electronic transponders. The audience, which by this time had dropped to a couple of hundred, was asked more than 50 questions about board services and real estate issues. Some of the “straw poll” results mirrored the earlier mood of the meeting. Asked if there should be a provision in board bylaws to allow for the removal of a member of the board of directors, 94 per cent said yes. Asked if the 16-member board of directors should be reduced, 55 per cent said yes.

 

Despite unhappiness over the current performance of the board’s TREBnet MLS system (61 per cent gave it a 1 out of 5), those in attendance gave board staff a vote of confidence. Staff received good marks for responsiveness to members, particularly at the membership help desk. Most of the board’s services and departments received positive feedback, but the group gave poor marks to the content, quality and distribution of Real Estate News; TREB’s media coverage; communication with members; enforcement of MLS rules; and financial management.

 

In the photo: David Pearce 

Share this article: