By Kathy Bevan
The new year began on a bright note for the Toronto Real Estate Board and the Canadian Real Estate Association, with the announcement in early January that Realtysellers is no longer pursuing legal action against those two organizations and their respective executives.
Toronto-based Realtysellers announced January 8 that it had settled its $25 million lawsuit out of court in December 2003 but that the ‘required terms’, including a financial settlement, had not been agreed to until January. Details of the final settlement were not disclosed.
The lawsuit was originally filed two years ago by Realtysellers co-founders Stephen Moranis and Lawrence Dale, in a legal attempt to resolve an advertising dispute with TREB’s Real Estate News. Last April, the claim was amended to include CREA and the chief executives of the Toronto board and the national association, citing alleged conspiracy and breaches of the Competition Act.
Realtysellers markets itself as a “full service for half the price” brokerage, offering a 1.25 per cent listing fee service, a flat fee “List on MLS for $695” service and a “half-back” buyers rebate package. In its lawsuit, Realtysellers accused TREB and CREA of restricting the firm’s access to MLS, which effectively shut down Realtysellers’ rollout strategy.
Realtysellers says the settlement reached with TREB and CREA will now allow the firm to move ahead with its plans to expand its services beyond its current locations.
“We’re already in Toronto, Hamilton, Ottawa and Barrie and are ready to move into other areas of Ontario, such as London, Windsor and St. Catharines, as well as other provinces, such as Alberta and B.C.,” says Moranis, who concedes that his firm may expand much more rapidly than originally planned, due to the national exposure Realtysellers and its business model gained through publicity given to its lawsuit.
“Indirectly, this has been a huge brand-building opportunity for us. But we didn’t strategically plan it that way – we were minding our own business when other segments of the industry circled their wagons around us,” says Moranis. “We just want to build a business where we see a tremendous opportunity to offer something different to consumers looking for choice. Litigation is a necessary evil when the whole company is at risk; now that this is settled, we believe everyone’s a winner.”
While Moranis referred to changes to “certain of the TREB MLS rules” as being a key factor in settling the lawsuit, neither Moranis nor TREB would state specifically what those changes are. What TREB and CREA made clear, however, in communication with their members, is that this agreement clears the way for Realtysellers and other discount brokers, as members of TREB, to have easier access to the MLS system to market for sale by owner properties.
However, “the MLS system does not provide for private sellers,” says Richard Wood, president of CREA, which owns the MLS trademark in Canada and licenses its use to real estate boards across the country. “It is a co-operative marketing system that a professional Realtor and real estate board member provides.”