Select Page

Former B.C. real estate agent ordered to pay $627,000 after commission scheme

A former British Columbia real estate agent has been ordered to pay $627,000 in penalties and enforcement expenses after the regulator found he deceived clients to collect higher commissions, among other misconduct.

The B.C. Financial Services Authority (BCFSA) has also cancelled the real estate licences of Andre Zubko and his personal real estate corporation following findings of professional misconduct, deceptive dealing and conduct unbecoming.

The penalties stem from eight property transactions in 2016 and 2017, when Zubko was working primarily in the Squamish area.

In a sanctioning decision dated Oct. 28, BCFSA hearing officer Andrew Pendray ordered $320,000 in discipline penalties and another $307,000 in enforcement expenses. It’s among the highest monetary penalties ever handed down by the regulator. 

Zubko’s misconduct also includes dishonesty and failure to cooperate during BCFSA’s investigation, according to a Nov. 13 news release.

Zubko has not held a real estate licence since 2017, when his renewal application was denied. 

 

How the commission scheme worked

 

According to a July 2024 liability decision, Zubko worked with two other real estate agents to obtain higher commissions than his listing agreements permitted, at his clients’ expense.

At the time, Zubko worked for One Percent Realty, a brokerage offering sellers reduced commission rates.

Under the arrangement, Zubko referred unrepresented buyers interested in his listings to the two agents, who then submitted offers requiring sellers to pay higher buyer-agent commissions than originally agreed upon.

Once the transactions closed, the agents returned most of the additional commission money to Zubko without his clients’ knowledge.

The arrangement occurred in all eight transactions. In four cases, Zubko “effectively acted for the buyers himself,” reads the BCFSA decision, while the other agents were identified as their representatives.

Across the eight transactions, sellers paid more than $50,000 in additional commissions, while Zubko received $47,641.23 in commission kickbacks.

 

Property assignments benefited acquaintances

 

In two instances, BCFSA found Zubko worked to coerce his seller clients to reduce the listing price on their properties to benefit Zubko’s close personal acquaintances, who would then purchase the properties and turn profits by assigning the contracts of purchase and sale at higher selling prices.

In one Squamish transaction, Zubko persuaded a seller to reduce an agreed purchase price from $350,000 to $175,000. The contract was subsequently assigned to another buyer for $335,000, generating a $160,000 assignment profit.

Pendray found the seller essentially lost $160,000 in sale proceeds because of Zubko’s actions.

In another transaction, Zubko fabricated information about a negative home inspection to convince a seller to reduce the purchase price from $807,000 to $797,000, despite knowing the contract had already been assigned for $845,000.

“It is difficult to imagine a more clear-cut case of deception of one’s client than completely making up a negative home inspection in order to convince that client to sell their property at a lower price,” Pendray wrote.

He described the assignment schemes as “what can only be described as severe misconduct.”

“In the assignment transactions, Mr. Zubko purposefully arranged transactions which would cause his clients to obtain less money from the sale of their property than Mr. Zubko in fact was fully aware they could earn,” he wrote.

The regulator also found Zubko failed to co-operate with its investigation, including deleting relevant emails, making false or misleading statements and meeting with others involved to align their accounts.

 

Penalties reflect seriousness of misconduct

 

In determining the sanctions, Pendray considered the financial harm to clients and the need to deter similar conduct.

Four transactions occurred before amendments to B.C.’s Real Estate Services Act increased the maximum discipline penalty from $10,000 to $250,000 per contravention. Those transactions each received the former maximum penalty of $10,000.

The remaining four transactions resulted in penalties totalling $275,000, with another $35,000 imposed in relation to remuneration Zubko received.

Zubko and his corporation acknowledged their conduct was wrong and dishonest but argued that BCFSA’s proposed sanctions were disproportionate. During the sanctions proceedings, Zubko also disputed some facts previously established in the liability decision.

They proposed approximately $85,000 in discipline penalties and $40,000 in enforcement expenses.

Pendray rejected the argument that penalties should be limited to the financial losses suffered by clients.

He warned that doing so would make monetary sanctions “just the cost of doing business in an inappropriate way, and only if one was caught.”

Zubko and his corporation are jointly and severally liable for the combined $627,000, payable within 60 days of the Oct. 28 decision. They also had 30 days from that date to appeal to the B.C. Financial Services Tribunal.

 

Share this article: