Traditional Canadian real estate companies should be concerned about Zillow and other new proptech companies that are capable of disrupting the traditional business model. Disruption will take place as the new companies take advantage of data and technology to streamline the real estate transaction process, while driving down costs and providing more relevant services to consumers.
My company, Insightt, closely monitors the U.S. real estate industry for early warning insights into what could and probably will take place in Canada. For this article, we reviewed the market cap, stock price and profitability of Zillow versus Realogy, which are both publicly traded companies on the U.S. stock exchange.
Zillow has brought change to the U.S. real estate industry with its impressive website, lead generation, property valuation model (Zestimate) and the acquisition of companies that are complementary within the real estate value chain.
Realogy is also an impressive real estate company that is categorized as traditional because it owns a number of traditional franchise brands, including Century 21, Coldwell Banker, Corcoran and Better Homes & Gardens. While Realogy has also introduced numerous innovative and positive changes to the U.S. industry, it remains largely dependent on the traditional real estate business model.
Is Zillow impacting traditional real estate companies like Realogy? The numbers tell the story. As shown in the chart below, Realogy reported a market cap that was seven times larger than Zillow in 2014. Fast forward to 2021and Zillow’s reported market cap is now more than 16 times greater than Realogy.
We know that market cap is not the entire story, so we also looked at the revenue and profit for each company in 2020 as shown below.
We also tracked the stock price of both companies over the past five years as shown below. Zillow’s current stock price is more than 10 times higher than Realogy’s stock price in U.S. financial markets.
Putting it all into perspective: Traditional real estate organizations must consider Zillow as a force to be reckoned with and taken seriously. They have a large market cap, they have better than industry margins and they have access to vast amounts of capital for the acquisition of additional companies in the real estate value chain.
We are not suggesting that established real estate companies in Canada need to raise the white flag yet, but they need to start heavily investing in technology and data before it’s too late. The next few years are about to get quite exciting in the Canadian real estate market. Zillow is now in Canada and many other new proptech companies are coming on the scene.
Brian Bell is a real estate and technology consultant. He is the lead principal for Insightt, which tracks new and innovative companies that are coming into the market through its Innovation Showcase. The company helps real estate related companies understand the risks of disruption, but more importantly helps them take innovation to the next level through data, technology and training.