Andrew Fogliato and Taylor Hack have spent the last few episodes of their weekly sales and marketing show building a niche marketing strategy in real time, using the Edmonton River Valley as the working example. The specifics are local. The underlying lessons are not.

Three moments from a recent episode are worth pulling out on their own, because each one applies to any agent in any market, regardless of what their chosen niche happens to be.

The listing description that promotes without promoting

Most listing descriptions read the same way: bedrooms, bathrooms, square footage, a line about the finished basement, a call to visit the agent’s website for more information. Fogliato suggested a small addition that does something different.

For an agent building a strategy around proximity to a park, trail system or other lifestyle feature, the description can include a single practical detail most competitors will never think to add: how many minutes it takes to walk to the nearest trailhead.

“It’s essentially non-promotional promotion for you in your own listing descriptions,” Fogliato said. “Because it’s information they want that they can’t easily get otherwise.”

The mechanism is straightforward. A buyer who cares about that detail notices immediately that this listing has it and others do not. They do not experience it as marketing. They experience it as useful information. But the fact that the agent tracked and included it signals something about how that agent thinks, which is the actual point. The reader draws their own conclusion about the agent’s expertise without being told to.

The same principle extends to any niche. An agent building a strategy around school catchment areas could note the walking distance to the relevant school. An agent focused on commuters could note the drive time to a specific highway on-ramp. The detail changes. The mechanism, useful information that quietly demonstrates specialised knowledge, does not.

Why small personal details quietly raise conversion rates

The second idea is less a tactic than a theory about rapport, and Fogliato illustrated it with details from his own office.

He described several objects in his workspace that are visible during video calls: a poster referencing a well-known comedy film, a small bust of Julius Caesar repurposed as a pen holder, and the effect they have when a client happens to recognise them.

“If someone mentions that poster, my conversion rate shoots up,” he said. “It’s rapport building.”

The reasoning is that shared cultural reference points create an instant, low-stakes form of connection. A client who notices and comments on a specific detail is signalling that they see the agent as a person rather than a service provider and that shift, however small, changes the tenor of the entire relationship that follows.

The detail does not need to be elaborate. It needs to be genuine and specific enough that noticing it means something. Fogliato described deliberately including references that only a small percentage of his audience would recognise, on the logic that the people who do catch them feel a disproportionately strong connection precisely because the reference was not aimed at everyone.

The broader lesson for agents building content or a personal brand: authenticity beats broad appeal. A detail that resonates deeply with a smaller audience does more for relationship-building than a generic detail that mildly appeals to everyone.

The sports blogger who never tried to be neutral

The third idea came from Fogliato describing a content strategy he used early in his real estate career, borrowed from a sports blogger he described as one of the first writers in that space to build a large audience without pretending to be neutral.

Most sports journalism at the time aimed for balance, a reporter’s job was to cover all teams fairly. This particular writer did the opposite. He wrote unapologetically as a fan of one city’s teams, invited strong reactions from people who supported rival teams, and treated that reaction as evidence that the content was working rather than a problem to fix.

“He was just as happy if you hated him,” Fogliato said. “Both sides were thrilled to see him in misery.”

Fogliato adapted the underlying idea, injecting a strong, specific point of view or cultural reference into otherwise dry content, into his own real estate marketing. One example he cited was rewriting a generic seven-tips post about buying a first home around quotes from a popular television character who was dominating cultural conversation at the time. The core content was unchanged. The framing made it something people wanted to read and share.

The lesson is not to copy any specific reference or personality. It is to identify what an intended audience already cares about deeply and let that interest carry otherwise ordinary information further than a neutral, generic version of the same content ever would.

Testing a niche before committing to it

The episode also worked through a practical question any agent building a niche strategy eventually has to answer: how do you know if the angle is actually working before investing months into it?

Fogliato’s suggested approach is a simple paired test. Take two pieces of content, the same format, the same general topic and vary only the niche-specific hook. In this case: a reel about the top neighbourhoods in a city generally, versus the same format naming a specific lifestyle feature like river or trail access. Run both as small paid tests, with a modest budget, and compare retention and engagement rather than guessing.

The test is deliberately narrow. It answers one question; does this specific angle outperform a generic version without requiring a large content library or a fully built-out strategy first? Only once that signal is clear does it make sense to build the fuller content architecture, the downloadable guides, and eventually any outside partnerships or collaborations the niche might support.

“I’d first do a really small-scale test,” Fogliato said. “Does this messaging get me better results than the non-specific version? That’s the easiest entry point.”

The full episode covers additional detail on structuring a phased rollout for a new content niche, how to think about audience overlap when expanding from one niche into an adjacent one, and how voice-of-customer research shaped the specific language used in the River Valley strategy.

Join the conversation live

Each week, The Leads Are Sh*t brings working agents together to dissect what’s actually working in real estate right now.

Be part of the live recording, get your questions answered and join the after-show conversation.

👉 Register for the next live session.

Related Posts