There is a version of a real estate career where you never run out of people to call, where your phone rings before you have to reach for it and where the people closest to you are your best source of consistent business.

Most agents know that version exists. Most of them never get there.

In a recent episode of their weekly sales and marketing show, Taylor Hack and Andrew Fogliato dug into why agents avoid talking real estate with the people they know, what the fear is actually signalling, and how to build a home team that produces consistently without ever feeling pushy.

Salesy is not a personality – it is a skill gap

The fear of coming across as pushy is one of the most common reasons agents stay quiet with their sphere. Hack’s take: that fear is a signal, not a character flaw.

“If you’re afraid of being salesy, it’s likely that you’re untrained,” Hack said. “You do need to be careful. You should have a strategy. Because otherwise you will come across as salesy – and that’s because you’re not good yet.”

The instinct to avoid it is right. The solution is not silence – it is skill. Agents who are bad at sales conversations should learn to have better ones, not avoid the topic entirely.

Fogliato noted the same dynamic plays out in how the public perceives real estate agents versus how they describe their own agent.

“Online they’re talking about the bad agents,” he said. “When they think of their agent, they’re great. Consultative. Has my back. Has my best interest at heart. Not the other agents. Those other ones we talk about online, those are the other ones.”

The home team: 300 people who would not walk past you

The foundation of Hack’s business model is what he calls the home team: a defined group of people who recognize you, would say your name specifically when asked for a real estate referral and are having regular real estate conversations with you.

The target number draws on research by anthropologist Robin Dunbar, whose work on social group sizes suggests that about 150 relationships is the upper limit for most people, with serious practitioners capable of maintaining around 300. A home team of 300 people who acknowledge a business-and-personal relationship with you should produce at least 30 deals a year from that group alone.

“If you open that door to have 100 real estate interactions with zero pressure, they just fly in,” Hack said. 

The failure mode is skipping that step entirely. Agents who do not have consistent real estate conversations with the people they know will lose those clients not to a competitor’s pitch but to availability. If a friend needs an agent and you are not the obvious first call, someone else is already there.

Research phase versus action phase

A key concept in Hack’s framework is the difference between contacts who are in a research phase and those who are genuinely action-ready. Treating everyone the same way destroys relationships with the former and misses opportunities with the latter.

Action-ready means something specific: if you put someone in a great home at a great price today, can they write an offer with standard conditions within roughly 10 days? If the answer requires selling a property first, securing financing, or waiting on external circumstances, they are not yet in the action phase.

“Two years means not now. That’s the only thing they can tell me,” Hack said. “If I’m not talking to them every 90 days, somebody else is.”

Fogliato added that timelines shift without warning. Someone who says two years may call the following week because a family member just bought a house, or a job changed, or a life event changed the plan.

“They weren’t lying. They meant two years a week ago,” Fogliato said.

What the flashlight trick actually teaches

One of Hack’s most effective tools at open houses has nothing to do with asking for business. When a buyer walks toward a window and looks at it, he pulls out his phone, holds the flashlight up to the glass, and shows them how to count the panes.

“It’s not the flashlight that gets them,” Hack said. “It’s the understanding of the problem that the flashlight solves – that they didn’t even know they had. They were looking at kitchens.”

Fogliato described a similar move from an agent he worked alongside early in his career, who would look at the edge of a window frame to read the manufacturing date, then do the mental math on remaining useful life on the spot.

The principle behind both is the same. The most effective way to demonstrate expertise is not to claim it but to solve a problem the prospect did not know they had. Fogliato described it as the two highest-performing types of content in any format: answering questions people have not thought to ask, and creating aha moments.

“You’re auditioning for a guide,” Hack said. “I know how to help in places you don’t even know exist yet.”

The open house goal is a next step, not a transaction

Hack is direct about what open houses are for. Less than one per cent of people who attend an open house end up buying that specific property. The value of the open house is database entries and next steps, not immediate conversions.

His opening question at every open house is designed to immediately split the room: “Did you have to come from far to be here today?” The answer tells him whether the person likely lives in the neighbourhood – which changes the conversation entirely.

From there, the goal is to collect timeline, family situation, motivation and enough context to have a reason to follow up. The conversation should not feel like a qualification call. It should feel like two people talking about property.

“You’re not showing up with engagement rings,” Hack said. “Talking to people about buying things and writing offers is how you scare the hell out of all of them. You’re at the nightclub. You’re not at the first date yet.”

Business cards: one contact side, one call to action

The back of a business card is where most agents waste space. Fogliato and Hack’s view is that the front should be what people expect – name, contact, brokerage – and the back should have exactly one thing: a compelling call to action.

The call to action should match the audience receiving it. A card handed to buyers at an open house should speak to buyers. A card given at a conference with other agents should mention referrals. A card for a listing-focused neighbourhood campaign should reflect that context.

“Sign up for my newsletter is not a call to action,” Fogliato said. “You need an actual reason. No one enters their email just because it says sign up for my newsletter.”

A call to action that has worked consistently in his own campaigns: “Become the smartest person in your neighbourhood about real estate in three minutes a week.” The outcome is specific, the time commitment is low and the reader immediately understands what they are getting.

Hack’s version for the insider list: a QR code on the card with a loading phrase like “learn what’s coming before it gets to Realtor.ca.” The card does one job. It creates a reason for someone to take the next step.

Check out the full episode for more on qualifying frameworks, how to build FORD depth (family, occupation, recreation, dreams) with personal contacts and the after-show discussion on ring cameras as a door-knocking strategy. 

Join the conversation live

Each week, The Leads Are Sh*t brings working agents together to dissect what’s actually working in real estate right now.

Be part of the live recording, get your questions answered and join the after-show conversation.

👉 Register for the next live session.

Related Posts